As with many of you, I am struggling to wrap my mind around the proverbial day after the elections. President Trump will drag this country to the mud, destroy all norms and minimize almost all of our key institutions. He will leave no room for civility and negotiation. Nonetheless, the work has to start shifting from election to reflection.
Thursday, November 5, 2020
The day after...
Sunday, October 25, 2020
The false narrative of black men lack of support for Sen. Harris
Let's help elect VP Biden and Senator Harris to bring dignity and decency back to the people's house.
Monday, October 5, 2020
Is November 3rd 2020 about the 1994 Crime Bill?
The 1994 crime bill has been one of the most vexing point in this election cycle and lynchpin argument of the Trump supporters as well as Russian trolls. They understand that there are people who genuinely have concerns about the bill's impact on our community. As is often the case, the Trump supporters are not only stretching the truth, they falsely claim that Senator Biden called blacks “super-predators.” History is recorded and has proven both of these claims to be unequivocally false.
- We can and must reduce the number of people incarcerated in this country while also reducing crime.
- Our criminal justice system cannot be just unless we root out the racial, gender, and income-based disparities in the system.
- Our criminal justice system must be focused on redemption and rehabilitation.
- No one should be profiteering off of our criminal justice system.
- 1 in 1,020 Black Americans has died (or 97.9 deaths per 100,000)
- 1 in 2,150 White Americans has died (or 46.6 deaths per 100,000)
Sunday, September 13, 2020
Human Decency is on the ballot in November
Haitian-Americans in Florida
During the 2016 presidential campaign, both major US presidential candidates, Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump, recognized not only the importance of Florida as a must-win state, but also the growing influence of the Haitian-American community as an electoral group. Trump won Florida by 112,911 votes or 1.19 per cent. Senator Rick Scott won with 10,033 votes (0.2 per cent) in 2018. Governor DeSantis won with 32,463 votes (0.4 per cent). In contrast, the Haitian electorate represents over 300,000 voters in Florida. If only half of those voters were registered Democrats and voted, they would have changed the outcome of all three elections.
Florida voted for Trump as it has voted for every winner of the Presidential election since 2000. Then-candidate Trump recognized the importance of the state and the weight of the Haitian-American electorate, at least enough to accept an invitation of Mr. Bernard Sansaricq to speak to the Haitian community of Florida in September 2016. Mr. Sansaricq, a former senator of the senate of Haiti had invited Donald Trump to meet with Haitian-Americans to share how his future administration would tackle the Haitian-community priority issues such as economic opportunities, healthcare, education, immigration and US foreign policy toward Haiti.
Candidate Trump promised to be our greatest champion
During that ill-fated 2016 visit, Mr. Trump praised the Haitian community, which he noted was filled with people who were “dedicated to family, perseverance, entrepreneurship.” He said that the Haitian-American community “deserves America’s gratitude and respect” and that he greatly respected our community, a statement that garnered great applause.
Trump further said that he followed what was unfolding in Haiti and shared in our pain. He said that all the things that make America "good and strong” could be found in Little Haiti and this was to be a “new chapter built on mutual respect and friendship and love.” He doubled-down to say that he was running to represent Haitian-Americans and would be our community’s “greatest champion.”
Actions speak louder than words
Fast forward to less than two years later, President Trump stated that Haitian immigrants to the U.S. “all have AIDS” and referred to Mexican immigrants as “rapists.” He also stated that Nigerian immigrants should “go back to their huts” and compared immigrants in general to snakes.
Although he has denied making those comments, his actions have spoken louder than any words could ever had. Indeed, in late 2017, he cancelled TPS designation for Haiti, one of his duly designated “shithole” countries as well as five others including: El Salvador, Honduras, Nepal, Nicaragua and Sudan.
We should not have any doubts about President Trump’s views on immigrants, blacks and for the Haitian-American community in particular. Despite President Trump’s many promises to be our champion, under his leadership, our community has been disproportionately impacted by Covid-19 and is experiencing higher economic hardship, and increasing gentrification due both to economics and climate change.
Across the country, there is mounting fear that families will be torn apart as a result of the cancellation of TPS designation for Haitians. On the foreign policy front, his administration supports a Haitian President who is decried by its people for deteriorating into authoritarian rule.
What to expect from a 2nd term
On bread and butter issues, as well as foreign policies, as Haitian-Americans, we recognize the sharp differences between the Democrats and Republicans. Whether the issues are the economy, a living wage, healthcare, how to tackle the Covid-19 pandemic, immigration and particularly TPS, education and the US foreign policy toward Haiti, one party has been inclusive and responsive while the other plays on fear as this President does. On the foreign policy front, every single overthrow of the democratic order (1988, 1991, and 2004) in the past 30 plus years has happened under Republican administrations.
As it has done over the past three plus years, a Trump administration will continue to promote white nationalism and supremacy, and fear as the centerpieces of its reelection campaign strategy. This is how President Trump hopes to get reelected and how he will govern – it will not be more of the same. It will be worse! He will foment racial division and wink at discrimination against minority communities. Additionally, he will consolidate policies that will govern our lives for the next 40 years, especially if he gets to nominate two more Supreme Court justices.
A reelection of President Trump will tear apart the fabric of what makes us all Americans.
Biden-Harris will fight for us
Although we know that it will take time to undo the harm caused by the current administration, we can start to dig ourselves out of the hole by electing VP Joe Biden and Senator Kamala Harris.
President Biden will reinforce the Affordable Care Act and introduce a new Medicare-like public option. This will ensure that no family has to turn to bankruptcy because of medical bills. He will rescind President Trump’s executive orders, which has affected thousands of Haitians and other immigrants and scrap the wealth test the Trump administration has proposed for prospective immigrants. A Biden administration will not separate families and put children in cages. He will forgive student debt for low-income and middle-class people who have attended public colleges and universities. He has made racial inclusivity an important pillar of his campaign and has demonstrated his commitment to racial equality by choosing Senator Kamala Harris as his running mate and nominating a number of African-Americans and Haitian-Americans to key posts in his campaign.
Above all, a Biden-Harris administration will bring honesty back to the White House and offer a vision to America that is aligned with our core values. As President Abraham Lincoln did, the Biden-Harris team will work to restore “our bonds of affection” and help us reconnect with the “better angels of our nature.”
We will stand for decency
We all know the role that the state of Florida will play again in the November election and must be under no illusion about Trump’s backing from supporters, including some Haitian-Americans, who do not have our interests at heart. Indeed, despite the Trump administration’s blatant racism and xenophobia, the Miami Herald recently published an article in which it reported on “an organized caravan of cars was blasting horns, waving flags and shouting through megaphones letting the world know about their support for President Donald Trump.”
In 2016, the Haitian community got played by a charlatan who promised to be our champion but became our community’s worst nightmare. This time, we must show that we learned from that mistake. Indeed, even Mr. Sansaricq, a staunch Republican and Trump supporter, has publicly distanced himself from the President.
Our community will not be played the fool again and we will not vote against our own interests. While there are many important issues at stake in this election cycle, the most important ones are human decency and civility. The question is whether we will vote for division or unity, will we stand for hate or love, will we go in the voting booth and select white nationalism and separatism over unity. We must ask ourselves whether we will raise our collective voice and use our votes to, once again, stand on the right side of history as we have done may times throughout America’s history.
Our modern-day "Vertières"
As Haitians, we launched the only successful slave-led revolution, which resulted in the first free black Republic. This desire for freedom was also present when a group of infantry volunteers from Saint Domingue called “Chasseurs Volontaires” fought valiantly alongside American troops in the 1779 Battle of Savannah against the British. A little over two decades later, some of those Haitians soldiers who fought in Savannah went on to fight for freedom and human dignity, and against slavery in Haiti. That war was so costly for the French that it forced Napoleon to sell its Louisiana and the Midwest territories, which doubled the size of the United States.
Our community can once again stand against tyranny and fight for freedom and human dignity. Though sadly this time, our stand will be against a President whom we mistakenly helped to elect to office. Haitian-Americans must stand shoulder to shoulder with our sisters and brothers from the Caribbean and Central-America to say no to tyranny. Together, we have the numbers to make the difference!
As the Haitian motto appropriately reminds us: Inite se fòs / L'Union fait la force ("Unity Makes Strength"). Si se puede!
Monday, August 24, 2020
Why Dimitri Vorbe not showing up to court does not matter
I firmly believe in the rule of law as the bedrock on which Haitian society can be rebuilt. And as Tiffany Madison aptly put it “When the Rule of Law disappears, we are ruled by the whims of men.”
This core belief has gotten me into trouble and have put me in the difficult position of defending people who do not need or even deserve my defense.
The rule of law
Essentially every aspect of public life requires a system of justice that works. It is easy to celebrate the arrest of Mr. Vorbes, whether it was by Interpol in the US or by the police in Haiti. However, accepting that a person, however bad they were, can be punished without due process is accepting that we will maintain the system of retribution . Worst, we would be ensuring that Haiti remains a country that is condemned to function with corruption.
Whether one believes that Mr. Vorbes is innocent or guilty of what he is being accused of is wholly irrelevant. One must critically question how what is being done impact not just one person but society at large.
We can start by asking ourselves the following questions:
- Has the government shown that Sogener’s invoices were inaccurate and or fraudulent?
- If so, was Sogener in cahoot with EDH and the justice of peace? And, if yes, have those public servants been arrested and charged?
- What is the impact of the government acting outside to the law to punish its opponents?
- What are the cascading effects to the judicial system?
- How will the regular citizens view themselves in this system and what will be the effects on the day-to-day relations?
Conclusion
To be clear, if it is proven in the courts that the Vorbes family defrauded the state then they should suffer the full consequences. But regardless of our personal feelings, the rule of law must prevail for Mr. Vorbe if it is to prevail for any of us.
As Haitian-Americans who care about our country of origin, it is imperative that we approach these issues from a system of value and convictions. We must situate issues like what is happening between the Haitian government and the Vorbes in a broader frame.
Wednesday, July 1, 2020
The slow walk toward authoritarian/dictatorial rule in Haiti
Let me expand on my rationale.
I think if you look at the literature on the rise of authoritarian rules and dictatorships, the strategy includes those governments' ability to "establish their own rules, including persuasion and coercion; personal characteristics; ideology and policies; the use of force and propaganda." This is textbook stuff and in that light the arrow is clearly pointing in the direction of an authoritarian rule in Haiti.
The President’s advisors studied from the same books and an observer can see how the tactics are playbook approaches of this very well-documented strategy. Here are a couple of ways in which this is done.
To start, the govt. creates its boogeymen and break the laws to attack said boogeymen. Of course, no one comes to the defense of the "bad guys" because they they are getting what they deserve. This tactic allows the govt. to use state powers to crush its enemies and silence civil society. Whether it is the electricity producers or the fuel importers, most people in civil society would not defend them because they are the "bad guys" who deserve what they are getting.
Next, the govt. disregards the growing insecurity and indeed creates an environment of impunity by disinvesting in the the police and judicial system. They it goes on to align itself with gang members, who they use to raze poor neighborhoods and commit unspeakable atrocities including mass murders. As a result of the environment of insecurity, when they go to Bel-Air, La Saline, Pont Rouge, or Shadda II which are areas that are supposedly opposition strongholds, it serves their electoral purposes. As they commit these crimes, civil society stays silent because it believes that these areas are full bandits and the cause of country's insecurity. However, the reports from human rights orgs. as well as the UN and even DCPJ have documented the direct implication of the government in human rights violations and massacres.
All the signs are there but to summarize I will highlight a few recent acts that standout. The govt. has:
- circumvented existing laws to confront and destroy their own effigies
- overrode existing rules and illegally use state funds to pay Dermalog
- imposed an unconstitutional new national ID cards
- published decrees that override existing laws
- used of gangs to consolidate political power and control
- attempted to modify the constitution on its own
- limited (violently) the right to peaceful assembly
I believe in a liberal democracy and Haiti is clearly and unambiguously moving away from that system of government. As we move further and further away from a liberal system we move closer and closer to what I see as the emergence of an authoritarian state and eventual dictatorship.
Saturday, June 13, 2020
Holding the police and politicians accountable
The existence of police brutality has always been the reality of people in poor communities, and especially the black community. With the ubiquity of video cameras, this reality is laid bare to the general public.
"What is often missed are the small and insidious ways in which this violence reveals itself."
Second, they (the politicians), they will propose the creation of new commissions. However, we have had dozens of commissions at the federal and local levels. During the Obama administration, it was called the “21st Century Task Force on Policing.” Under the current one, it’s called the Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of Justice. Whether Republicans or Democrats, after every high-profile police killing, politicians promise reforms but once dust settle, they either slow-walk the recommendations that were made by their commissions or the cities and the police departments outright ignore the consent decrees. It is not difficult to see why the context has deteriorated:
- Some police officers, who may already see the community as their enemy, are then given a quota by their leadership, which translates into stops and frisks so they can make the numbers.
- Politicians who are elected by the people are often more afraid of the police unions than they are of the people who elected them.
- The courts have shown leniency to officers who have openly flaunted and clearly violated the public trust.